« Getting Rolled By Obama Is A Wake-Up Call for the Uprising | Home | EFCA »

A Typical Day in the Wild West Bank

The deteriorating situation in the West Bank is somewhat of a forgotten story at the moment, but deteriorating it is. A random look at stories that appeared in yesterday's press show how dreadful the situation has become. It is on the West Bank that the two-state solution will ultimately be realized--or collapse. The Gaza ceasefire is crucial, but it's the realities in the West Bank that are eroding the achievability of a peace agreement everyday.

Here's a sampling of stories:

- The Government of Israel's refusal to comply with High Court rulings which have required restriction of the scope of the security barrier being constructed in the West Bank (as documented in a new B'Tselem report)

-The EU and Middle East envoy of the Quartet Tony Blair's insistence that Israeli checkpoints and blockade of Gaza are negatively impacting Palestinian aid efforts and prospects for economic improvements

-The revelation that the settlers of the Amona outpost have illegally built a road through land determined as Palestinian under the Oslo Accords. Of course the "unauthorized" Amona outpost is still standing despite constant official Israeli commitments to the U.S. to remove all outposts.

-Data presented by human rights group Yesh Din arguing that only 10% of Palestinian claims of Israeli settler violence end up as indictments filed against the suspects

-That Palestinians in the West Bank are facing the prospect of chronic water shortages resulting from Israeli restrictions

So, that's the daily round up folks. What is perhaps most depressing is that little of this can even be explained as the intentional policy decisions of the current Israeli Government - the Olmert Government seems genuinely interested in a two-state deal and easing rather than entrenching the occupation - even if it still cannot bring itself to do what is necessary either in practice or even declaratively by openly expressing a willingness to withdraw to the 1967 lines but for minor, agreed and mutual modifications. The shocking reality of the occupation in its 42nd year is that Israel knows little else (Israel has occupied the West Bank for over two-thirds of its existence) and policies today, like those mentioned above, largely operate on auto-pilot. Inertia as much as ill-will keep the settlement enterprise rolling along, the checkpoints, the "Jewish-only" use road-systems ...etc - and that inertia is strangling the future for both Palestinians and Israelis. It is truly tragic and limp-wristed American policies have played a dramatic role in facilitating the tragedy.

One of the problems is just how ill-informed the debate in the U.S. often is on these issues. One daily source of information for many who follow Israel and the Middle East is something called the Daily Alert, produced by the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs (JCPA). You can read their coverage of the litany of West Bank troubles here- it won't take you long, in fact it won't take you any time at all, to notice that the Daily Alert makes no mention whatsoever of any of these stories.

Yet the Daily Alert is a major source of information for the American Jewish community (prepared as it is on behalf of the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations). Fair enough - the publication is unlikely to be a 'this is what Israel does wrong-fest', but it does a disservice by covering the news from such a skewed angle - it's the Fox News American Jewish e-publication.

And it is highly political - the JCPA is run by Dore Gold, former PM to Benjamin Netanyahu, and has a very pronounced and unsurprising right-wing bent. JCPA's key contributors read like a who's who of the Israeli academic right, including many of the Israeli echo chamber for America's neocons. Its selective culling of news and analysis has an aggressively hawkish orientation - and begs two questions - why do mainstream Jewish organizations that are part of the Conference of Presidents allow this to be put out in their names and is it any wonder that the policy debate in America is so tragically misguided...



Comments (8)

avatar

i finally got my decoder ring working. now i know what the policy of the israeli government is in regards to the palestinian issue, no matter what what the government officially says. it's really quite simple: whatever the settlers do, that is israel's real policy. that is what is behind the curtain. it's not pretty.

avatar
What is perhaps most depressing is that little of this can even be explained as the intentional policy decisions of the current Israeli Government

This statement reveals self delusion. It may not be the openly stated policy, but how can you say it is not "intentional". During the Oslo process the stated policy of Israel was to provide lands on the westbank for a new Palestinian state. However during that period the number of settlers increased from 200k to 400k. That was no accident. That had to be intentional even if official Israeli statements denied such. Olmerts policy is no different.

avatar

Another thing I find depressing is Obama's foreign trip itinerary - that he plans to go to Israel but not to Palestine. How biased is that?

avatar

There were recent news that IDF is raiding bussinesses in West Bank, closing and confiscating, accusing them of --- cooperating with Hamas, while allegedly there is a ceasefire with Hamas.

Usually there is a ceasefire, after many months of non-negotiations, and then a series of assasinations and other provocations makes a short work of it. Palestinians are perpetually at fault anyway.

And then, bwahaha, Palestinian will "support extremists", so extremists have to be isolated, so they get support (however feeble) from Syria, so Syria has to be isolated, so Syria can get aid only from the theocracy of Iran, so Iran has to be isolated, but Russia is selling weapons to Iran and China wants to invests there, so we have to isolate Russia, China, and perhaps India for a good measure.

(Many) Israelis have schisophrenia. In the short term, they have no problems, so any "sacrifices for peace", like less beastly behavior in West Bank, are foolish and unrealistic. In the long run, it does not look so rosy, so the response is paranaia and talk of genocide. The combination of utter confidence and abject paranoia is the chief characteristic of "Likudnik" worldview (but how Likudnik it is if Barak subscribes to it?).

avatar

piotr:
Sadly, your post captures the essence of the situation much better than much of what I've read over the last few years (with a few exceptions, such as Levy's work, of course).

It just seems to get worse and worse and I can't imagine what will possibly change it.

Daniel: Thanks for bringing us an update on what's actually going on in the West Bank. There really has seemed to be a dearth of information lately (not that there's generally much anyway), probably because of the U.S. elections.

Dore Gold has been working with One Jerusalem, a group devoted to keeping Jerusalem entirely under Israeli sovereignty. This would of course be completely unsatisfactory to the Palestinians, who intend to make East Jerusalem their capitol upon the conclusion of a peace agreement, and so is a serious impediment to any real peace.

Here's more about what Gold has said to One Jerusalem: http://www.onejerusalem.org/blog/archives/2008/01/exclusive_one_j_1.asp

avatar

it takes one to know one:

'This is like apartheid': ANC veterans visit West Bank

avatar

The "round up" of news from the West Bank? It looks like only one side of the story, of Israel's transgressions (real and imagined.)
There are two road systems because of chronic attacks on cars with Israeli plates. Abbas isn't doing much to control violence emanating from the West Bank, so Israel has to protect itself. It also has to stop a Hamas takeover. Did anyone here protest when, after Israel completely dismantled all the settlements in Gaza, Hamas took over by force from Abbas/PA? Since then, and even since the "truce," rockets fly to civilian territory in Israel "proper" (behind 1948 armistice line.)
Some of the arguments presented here make every Arab state out to be powerless. History shows otherwise. Is Iran not a real threat? Are there new long-range missiles for peaceful purposes, like their nuclear program? Don't worry, I DO NOT advocate invading or attacking Iran. But Hezbollah, with Iranian backing, is slowly taking over Lebanon, mostly by force. Does anyone care about that? Or is it all the fault of Israel.
There is plenty of information about what Israel does, including in the West Bank. But there isn't much information about what Hamas or the PA is doing. No free press there.
It just doesn't wash that the "Zionist conspiracy" has such a hold on the world. Who has the oil? Who is surrounded by countries that (with two exceptions) have not made peace? Hamas refuses to recognize the right of Israel to exist with any borders at all (1948, 1967).
I happen to think Israel's policy of expanding and enhancing the settlements is wrong, morally and strategically. But the sins and power do not reside only on one side, and to think they do is not a basis to find a solution.

avatar

How much access do Isralis such as Daniel Levy, Alon Liel, Ephraim Halevy have to the "opinion elites" in NYC and DC?

More importantly, do politicians have exposure to those Israelis with differing viewpoints on who can be talked to?

access.

@dcsmithie.

This one's for you:

" {Hamas}Deputy Politburo Chief Moussa Abu Marzouk told Asharq Al-Awsat following the recent talks the Islamist group held with Egyptian mediator Omar Suleiman that

........

According to the Palestinian sources, Suleiman asked the Hamas representatives to learn from Hizbullah's experience in conducting negotiations with Israel and keep the details of the burgeoning prisoner swap deal confidential."
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3566947,00.html

Hezbollah and Israel have had lots of practice cutting deals over the years although neither side enjoys it much.

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


August 18-22

Book Cover

September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address