« Put a Woman in Charge? | Home | SEIU's Grover Norquist Strategy »

Put a Woman in Charge?

Even as Hillary Clinton exits the U.S. race for president, the leadership race is in full swing in Israel. The woman to watch: Tzipi Livni.
As Israel's Prime Minister Ehud Olmert is in freefall after one too many corruption scandals, the men are circling the wagons to prevent Foreign Minister Livni from gaining the top post. She's one of the most popular politicians in Israel and practically the only potential candidate without the stain of previous scandal, but for her to win, she'll have to get past her own party primary first. How she does will gravely impact the peace process and the future of the U.S. role in the region, too.

Yesterday's Israeli papers reported that deals are being cut between Israeli Labor Party leader Ehud Barak and a much weaker (and more right wing) Kadima Party leader, against Livni, Shaul Mofaz, to try to deny Livni the top post from her own Kadima Party. Mofaz, like Barak, a former IDF Chief of Staff, is a weak candidate in the national arena in Israel, a conservative who doesn't appear to have any real vision for the country or the vision--and Barak, well, it's difficult to know what Ehud Barak, the Labor Party leader (and Israel's most decorated former IDF Chief of Staff) believes these days.

The hope is that if Livni's support builds, Barak will move toward Livni if he can't defeat her and together, they could build a center-left block that could be in place to move finally toward an agreement with the Palestinians and be in shape for a major U.S. role to be played if Obama wins.

Rather than those who truly seek peace in the region --a just, two-state solution--to continue to parse what Obama said to AIPAC or what he will say every day up to Election Day and beyond, I would suggest that the action is more in Israel right now than in the U.S. U.S. pronouncements about a united Jerusalem (and the ridiculous statement about moving the U.S. Embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem that Senator McCain resurrected end of this past week), mean little in real time, quite frankly. Today, Haaretz newspaper is reporting that Livni and top Palestinian negotiation Ahmed Queria, are writing up a declaration of principles for settlement. This is Livni's election platform. I can guarantee you that moving the U.S. Embassy is nowhere in her plan. That plot of land still sits in southern Jerusalem unplowed as it will remain.

Without a strong Israeli government that is committed to move peace forward, no matter who the U.S. president is, things will continue to falter. Bibi Netanyahu is ahead in the polls now, as he usually is whenever he is a candidate and the outlook for peace appears a distant glimmer, but it's not unlikely once the campaign over there begins for real--and voters are reminded of Bibi's own personal failings not simply his retrograde politics, Livni's numbers will surpass him, if she can get past the boys in the Knesset.


Comments (8)

We need more estrogen and less testosterone on the world scene, and I'm thinking of Mary Robinson not Hillary Clinton.

I'll take wisdom and vision, without regard for the chromosomes behind it.

avatar

If she followed the primaries here in the states, she has a leg up on the competition in Isreal.

The news you report that "Livni and top Palestinian negotiation Ahmed Queria, are writing up a declaration of principles for settlement" is welcome news. Bibi is quite the force in Israel with his coalition on the Right.

I feel so frustrated by the US role (or non-role) in recent years that I can barely follow the politics. So many American Jews who say they support peace have moved to the right. I know Jewish liberals (with health insurance) who say that without Clinton in the race they are thinking about McCain. Madness.

With time running out on Bush, what are the chances of Israeli participation in any kind of action against Iranian nuclear facilities? Something I think that Bush is considering, to give McCain a victory, and strike his final act of biblical violence.

avatar

I'm very encouraged by Tzipi Livni's rise to power within Israel and the respect she has earned in the world's capitals. No doubt her experience in the IDF and the Mossad impresses those who care about such things.

The fact that Ariel Sharon saw her promise is instructive as is her ability to do end runs around the boyz club when called for. The boyz froze her out of discussions dealing with matters military during the stupid summer war of '06 so Livni simply tapped into her own contacts in order to keep apprised of the situation. Heh.

Tzipi Livni cannot be faulted on her Zionist credentials although her pragmatism gives the radical rightists plenty of pause. Livni is the next best hope for Israel and this quote from a Richard Cohen NYT 7/08/07 profile indicates that she and President Obama will be able to talk to eachother:

"But, I asked her in our first meeting, are you good at persuading people? "Eehhh, ummmm, yes, I am good at persuading people," she managed in that quieter voice, before declaring that she does not like to speak about herself and finally mustering, "In convincing the other, I try to start from their point of view, so it's easier for me to find a common denominator."
http://www.israel-palestina.info/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=583

I also suspect that PM Livni will be well regarded in the Arab/Muslim worlds if these observations from one of the commenters on "Syria Comment" is indicative:

"ausamaa said:

..........

But peace between Syria and Israel anytime soon? Forget, and let us not forget that for Syria, it has to go in parallel with the Palestinian issue which is going nowhere now.

I think Tzivni Livi, daughter of Eshkol, ssems the only one to have the legitimacy, the nervs and the guts to become another Rabin and reach the moment of truth before the moment of truth is upon us with thousands of Syrian and Israeli rockets and tanks head towards their possible destinations.

May 21st, 2008, 7:58 pm

Qifa Nabki said:

Ausamaa said:

{snip}.......

You just think she’s cute. ;-)

May 21st, 2008, 8:02 pm

ausamaa said:

That helps, would it not…. and she is as not a teaser like Condi.

No, seriously, I love the arroagant way she treats Olmert and the rest of the politicians in Israel. It like she is forced to sit among idiots and wannabes, but not among equals."
http://joshualandis.com/blog/?p=722

I couldn't help but smile at reading that last observation as I recalled a revealing photo of Tzipi confronting Bush in the Oval Office. She was facing him directly, her finger in the lecture/admonish mode and damned if he didn't appear cowed.

avatar

Where does this Tzipi Livni is a woman of peace come from? I have seen some statements from her that seem to put her well on the right. Can't say that I really know her politics, but it seems from her background that she came up through Likud.

Am I mistaken here? Israel has already had one women PM. Have we forgotten Golda "there is no such thing as a Palestinian" Meir? Along with Indira Ghandi and Margaret Thatcher, I don't buy that women are any less warlike than men when they achieve political power.

I tried to write a response to this but deleted it. Comparing internal US politics to internal Israeli politics seems like a useless exercise.

avatar

syvanen.

Livni did come up through the Likud and split to Kadima. She's a hawk of course; no viable Israeli pollitician can afford to be anything else. Livni sems to pose the biggest threat to the male aspirants in Israel and it appears that there may be some ad hoc alliances forming in order to thwart her. As is said in a fascinating Haaretz piece by Yossi Verter, "Mofaz's greatest supporters are Netanyahu and Barak. If they could, they would establish a nonprofit association: PMS - Political Mofaz Supporters."

Given that it's rumored that Bibi may hire Karl Rove, the following excerpt is appropo (and funny):

"The truth, they admit with frustration in the Likud, is that there isn't much to work with here. The paradox is that it is impossible to find anything on her because she has not done much. How often can we say that she is unsuitable when our candidate, Bibi, is considered to have been one of Israel's most unsuccessful prime ministers? And how often can we say that she isn't experienced enough, when his legacy is so problematic?

Let's say, one of the Likud heads mused aloud this week, that we produced a television advertisement like that of Hillary Clinton: The red telephone rings at 3 A.M. at the Prime Minister's Residence in Jerusalem. On the line, a military adviser reports that Iran is moving its rocket launchers. Will the public really want Bibi to be the one who answers that call? "
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/990645.html

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover

Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address