TPMCafe
« Veepstakes Open Thread | Home | McCain on "Nuclear Security" »

Obama is back!

user-pic

For a while, on the long and torturous campaign trail, Obama seemed to focus excessively on the easier side of communitarianism: that we are all one; the hope and joy of togetherness. However, during his recent Wesleyan speech he revived the other half of his message: the call for service for the common good, a much more demanding subject.

For a time, we heard a lot of "we are not from red states, not from blue states, but from the United States." We were invited to join the feel-good politics sprinkled liberally with the holy water of hope which has no cost.

In The Audacity of Hope, written before Obama declared his bid for the presidency, he was more mindful of the other half of the communitarian message, that we should "ground our politics in the notion of a common good." He wrote, "We value the imperatives of family and the cross-generational obligations that family implies...We value patriotism and the obligations of citizenship, a sense of duty and sacrifice on behalf of our nation."

On the campaign trail many of these profound insights faded. We heard painless declarations, such as "Our prosperity can and must be the tide that lifts every boat...we rise or fall as one nation," and such undemanding observations as "...too often, we lose our sense of common destiny; [the] understanding that we are all tied together."

The nation is upon hard times. Its coffers are empty; creditors are at the gate; the military is exhausted and depleted; the regard in which America is held overseas is at an all time low; and major economic and security challenges pile up like so many storm clouds. The nation demands a prolonged period of restoration, one in which merely replenishing all that was squandered will entail raising taxes and keeping new expenditures on a tight leash. In plain English-- restoration means sacrifices and a commitment to serve, to give rather than just to take.

At Wesleyan, Obama re-embraced this theme. He told the graduating class--and the rest of us-- about the days in which he first served as a community organizer in Chicago: "...I had worked for weeks on this project. We waited and waited for people to show up, and finally, a group of older people walked into the hall. And they sat down. And a little old lady raised her hand and asked, 'Is this where the bingo game is?'"

He continued, "It wasn't easy, but eventually, we made progress. Day by day, block by block, we brought the community together, and registered new voters, and we set up after school programs, and fought for new jobs, and helped people live lives with some measure of dignity."

Better yet, he introduced a new note, one of great import: "I also began to realize that I wasn't just helping other people. Through service, I found a community that embraced me; citizenship that was meaningful; the direction that I'd been seeking. Through service, I discovered how my own improbable story fit in to the larger story of America."

If you want to read more, go here, but the main point is clear: unless we all put our shoulders to the wheel, America with be stuck in the rut that it is in now. Right on, Obama.


Amitai Etzioni is the author of The Spirit of Community and a sociology professor at The George Washington University. He can be reached at coment@gwu.edu. www.securityfirstbook.com


11 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

. . . the call for service for the common good, a much more demanding subject.

"Call for service"? That suggests voluntarism. Fuggetaboutit!

Let's put all young people in slave labor camps, the sooner the better.

user-pic

Lol...and...first they came after the jungen, then, the angry jungen payback: xxx hours per week volunteering required before you get that Social Security check?

Joking aside, I think Mr. Etzioni is making a connection between a pretty standard graduation ceremony speech ("give something back to the community for your education" is basically the general theme at such events) and eventual presidential policy, and I think it's possible that that connection just might not be there, that perhaps he was just giving your basic graduation speech.

Too bad about his comments in San Francisco.

I just want to let everybody know, for historical reference, that this was the day the Steamship Empress of Ireland sank and 1,024 people drowned.

I just automatically think of May 29 as Empress of Ireland Sinking Day, in case that ever pops up in conversation and it seems inexplicable or inappropriate to you. That's just how I remember it's May 29.

So don't freak out or make a big deal out of it if I bring it up.

user-pic

A call to what kind of service, exactly?

And I don't think that raising taxes and cutting expenditures is the right thing to do right now. If that's the communitarian economic plan, it's pretty flimsy.

We can raise taxes on the people who can afford it, but we should also be raising exenditures in order to rebuild our infrastructure and to stimulate the economy. The government should be investing in the country right now. That means expenditures need to rise.

Does it worry you that you don't know what his policy is?

user-pic

Etzioni or Obama?

user-pic

Rec'd. A worthy companion to Dreams from the Left: The Shape of Things to Come

http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/2008/05/dreams-from-the-left-the-shape.php

And, yes, Obama's been talking infrastructure, along with all the other generic communitarian appeals that I'm a sucker for.

user-pic

I challenge Mr./Ms. Lamont to actually listen to this speech and will venture to guess that the poster dismissed Obama's speech based only on this secondary [laudatory] source rather than on primary-source research.

The clear indicator of a lazy commenter? "perhaps he was just giving your basic graduation speech."

It's not long. Listen first. Recall that this was a speech given at Wesleyan at the request of Senator Kennedy and in place of the ailing Senator - so it had great meaning for both Mr. Obama and for - among others - Senator Kennedy's graduating daughter and for his son - who broke down at one point as Mr. Obama spoke. Then come back with your ennui.

Or better yet - take a low paying job as Mr. Obama did - as I did [in my case with ACORN in 2003 - trying to assist homeowners into lower-interest loans who were being burdened by predatory home loans that also included huge pre-pay penalties] - and after you've done service.
THEN come back. If your ennui remains intact you are welcome to it.

Take the challenge?

user-pic

Mr. Etzioni - a small offering to you for doing TPM readers the honor of noting Obama's fine call to service: a very short note by James Fallows found courtesy of a commenter on the Jesus' General Blog (itself an astonishing compilation of eloquent literary/political critique and sarcastic politico/religious take-downs):
(I strongly recommend reading the original at The Atlantic - and much else by Fallows)

FALLOWS' ORIGINAL AT URL:
http://jamesfallows.theatlantic...._subtle_art.php

Obama at Wesleyan: a subtle elegance I missed the first time

27 May 2008 11:20 pm

Via reader Rachel, a heads up on a sublime aspect of Barack Obama's recent commencement speech at Wesleyan. (Previously on the speech here and here.)

To review: Obama was there in place of the ailing Teddy Kennedy. Kennedy had given Obama a huge boost in the legitimacy-and-legacy category by endorsing him, even if it didn't help much in the MA. primary. And Kennedy's most famous speech was his "concession" speech at the 1980 Democratic convention in New York, when he brought the house down (I was there) with his defiant reassertion of the liberal values that he thought the doomed incumbent, Jimmy Carter, had abandoned. His speech ended with these words:

For me, a few hours ago, this campaign came to an end.

For all those whose cares have been our concern, the work goes on, the cause endures, the hope still lives, and the dream shall never die.

The structure of Obama's speech, these 28 years later, built toward praise of Kennedy's legacy and record, and ended with these words:

That is all I ask of you on this joyous day of new beginnings; that is what Senator Kennedy asks of you as well, and that is how we will keep so much needed work going, and the cause of justice everlasting, and the dream alive for generations to come.

As Rachel points out, this ending was

an allusion so subtle that Kennedy himself might be the only person who caught it. Obama took the speech of Ted's lifetime... and put the three key words - work, cause, dream - into the last line of the text. Poetry into prose, a private tribute to the man whose endorsement took Obama from runner up to winner.

What is so elegant about this touch? Precisely that Obama did not feel obliged to spell out all the links. ("And what I ask of you, in Senator Kennedy's own unforgettable words...") Politicians shouldn't be obscure. But a willingness to assume good things about the public -- its knowledge, its understanding, its ability to rise above the most immediate appeal to pocketbook or prejudice -- is part of what makes a politician into a leader. Even if the intended audience for this close was strictly the Kennedy family, it is an impressive bit of craftsmanship.

FALLOWS' ORIGINAL AT URL:
http://jamesfallows.theatlantic...._subtle_art.php

Note the way Obama links the hope and the dream by saying, "dream," in the spot where Kennedy said, "hope." I think he further stresses the unity between hope and dream (to those familiar with the first speech) by saying "the dream alive." And, of course, you don't need to catch this reference to be stirred by the speech.
Say what you want about Obama, he can sure as hell give a speech.

Kennedy's words:

For all those whose cares have been our concern, the work goes on, the cause endures, the hope still lives, and the dream shall never die.

Obama's:
...that is how we will keep so much needed work going, and the cause of justice everlasting, and the dream alive for generations to come.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Kyle Krahel-Frolander



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address