The Ultimate Standard Bearer for the Christian Right
Many readers have noted that, despite my book’s subtitle, How James Dobson, Focus on the Family, and Evangelical America are Winning the Culture, my posts so far have been about Dobson’s slipping grip on the Christian Right as evangelicals branch out beyond abortion, gay marriage, and returning religion to the public square. But the truth remains that Dobson is the most powerful Christian Right standard bearer that the movement has ever known. That’s because Dobson, unlike Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, or Ralph Reed, cultivated a huge following by dispensing family advice and helping people through crises in their personal lives—not by brandishing his political views. The same is true of Focus on the Family, the most powerful political organization in Christian Right history despite the fact that most of its work is not overtly political.
In 1977, while on sabbatical from the University of Southern California—where he’d gotten a Ph.D. in psychology and was, at the time, teaching in its medical school—Dobson launched his first radio show. Four years later, he expanded the 15-minute weekly program into a 30-minute daily format. Within a decade, the daily broadcast had been picked up by nearly 800 stations nationwide. “The majority of Christian radio programming at that time was pastors who would edit their preaching from a Sunday service and put it on the radio,” remembered Peb Jackson, who joined the Focus on the Family board of directors in 1977. “There weren’t many talk shows. There were shows with missionaries and about Church people doing things, but this was different.”
Dobson’s avuncular manner and his capacity for letting grown men break down with tape rolling were a sharp break with Christian radio’s customary fire-and-brimstone sermons.
To a no-frills evangelical radio culture inhabited by graying, out-of-touch preachers, Dobson brought all the professionalism of his medical CV to bear, interviewing contemporary Christian authors about the challenges of bringing up kids and leading happy marriages. But Dobson was no softy. Defying the affirmation-heavy tactics of the psychologists who were cropping up on television and radio in response to a generation of therapy-hungry baby boomers, he applied the same rules-based approach as Dare to Discipline, his first book. “During those years, psychologists were not prone to give answers—they were more prone to draw you out,” recalled Jackson. “Jim was never shy about giving answers. He did not hem and haw around with folks and say ‘Tell me how you’re feeling.’ He’d say, ‘Let me tell you what I think.’”
The subject matter, and Dobson’s practical approach, won him an overwhelmingly female listenership. He encouraged parents to talk to their kids about sex and sexuality before the onset of puberty. He opined that masturbation, a controversial subject among many religious Americans, “is not much of an issue with God.” And even as he was uncompromising on premarital abstinence, asserting that the harshest consequence of premarital sex is the “judgment of God in the life to come,” he stressed that it’s never too late to reverse course and become a “secondary virgin.” “His folksy style made listeners believe that he was their friend,” recalled former Focus on the Family chief operating officer Paul Nelson. “And they wanted to help him because of it.”
Dobson was intensely aware of that fact. Early on, he perceived that his broadcast, by connecting him to listeners every day, presented him the opportunity to win their trust and to help instill in them an orthodox Christian worldview that rejected the reigning postmodernism. “He was skeptical as to the lasting impact of just speaking once to any group,” said Jackson. “He was more interested in long-term relationships. That was why the daily radio show was a perfect medium. He is in your face every day, talking about the issues and values and he felt that happened over a period of time…. You could get people whipped up with music or by a great speaker, but he felt radio was transformational—transformational in helping people define their thinking on issues.”
Dobson had incorporated his speaking and media ventures as Focus on the Family in 1977, but his most important innovation came in 1979, when he hired five women to answer the letters that had been pouring in at a rate of more than a hundred a day in response to his radio show. Dobson’s fans were writing to him for two reasons. One was to order something from Focus’s growing repertoire of books, pamphlets, videos, and taped broadcasts that they’d heard or heard about on Focus on the Family. The other was to ask for Dobson’s advice on a wide array of topics. The letters asked about proper potty training techniques, how to confront a cheating husband, and countless other matters. By the early ’80s, Dobson was receiving thousands of letters a month. He’d hired more than 60 staffers to answer the mail, who came to be known at Focus as “correspondents.” The organization also hired a team of part-time Christian therapists to call troubled “constituents,” as Dobson called the people that wrote and called him and Focus.
Though Focus on the Family never required payment for its advice and advertised “suggested donations” for its products rather than firm prices, financial support was quick in coming. By 1987, the ministry had a roughly $34 million budget, more than Christian Coalition’s at its high point a decade later, and almost all from individual donors. By 1995, Focus’s budget topped $100 million. In contrast to donors who support charities like the Salvation Army or to ministries like Campus Crusade for Christ, donors to Focus benefited personally from their donations, by listening to Dobson’s show, having access to a warehouse of reasonably-priced Christian resources, and knowing someone was out there if they ever needed some free guidance. “People didn’t feel like they had to give a dime, and with that credibility, people would get on the mailing list and we developed this sense of communication,” said Jackson. “The idea was not just to be a resource for people to tap into when they listened to the radio show. We wanted to design a superstructure of assistance to people that went deep.”
To Dobson, the survival and growth of his organization depended on each individual who called or wrote to Focus getting speedy, customized help. Phone calls were to be answered in three rings. Answering services or automated phone attendants were out of the question. Letters were to be turned around in three days. Dobson reviewed constituent mail and built broadcasts around what was on his listeners’ minds. “It shocked people at times to realize [Dobson’s] need to satisfy the customer,” recalled Jackson. “He would find out if phone calls were not answered or mail wasn’t answered or if something was not promised or did not get to a person… With his own massive personality and effort, he kept everyone’s nose to the grindstone.”
With a line of best-selling books, a popular film series, a widely distributed radio show, and a rapid-response call and letter-writing operation, Focus on the Family had developed a full-blown evangelical media empire by the mid-1980s. The organization sent monthly letters and occasional fundraising pitches to each person who called, further cementing its relationship with constituents. By 1985, Focus had collected 700,000 names and addresses. A decade later, Focus cleared 2 million names. “The marketing was just incredible,” said Nelson, the former Focus chief operating officer. “I was always putting the brakes on, saying we have to be careful because we can sell a dog on [Dobson’s radio show]. I told Jim, ‘For crying out loud, you can go the mountain with some heresy and 100,000 people will follow you there, because the marketing was there.”
As the ’90s approached, Focus’s correspondence department wanted to study other big letter writing operations. The only similarly sized effort was managed by the White House, so Focus flew the White House’s letter-writing supervisor to its Southern California headquarters. “The woman was amazed at our system, that we were every bit as efficient as the White House,” remembered then correspondence department supervisor Diane Passno. “I felt good about that, because we were flying by the seat of our pants. We just knew we had to answer the mail. We didn’t know what we were doing.”
But Dobson knew. Unlike leaders of other Christian ministries, Dobson was so confident in pursuing his vision for Focus on the Family that he wasn’t afraid to hire business world executives into the top tiers of Focus management to see that it be carried out. “He has a confidence, sometimes even arrogance… he had such a belief in what he felt God had given him in both his purpose and his expertise,” Jackson said. “Jim had the uncanny ability that even when his fellow professionals were going in one direction and he had a belief in something that was counter, and he was the only fish swimming upstream, it didn’t make any difference... If everybody was on the same train in one direction, it almost made it more delicious for him to go in the opposite direction.”















He's like a right wing Oprah Winfrey.
thosethingswesay.blogspot.com
March 23, 2007 7:45 AM | Reply | Permalink
Dobson's real and lasting gift to the world - better customer service.
March 23, 2007 7:53 AM | Reply | Permalink
Classic!
March 23, 2007 7:58 AM | Reply | Permalink
You know, I wonder an awful lot about Christiasns who seem to have forgotten about that whole Jesus thing about the rich man in heaven and camels through needle's eyes.
Ben Cronin
March 23, 2007 8:12 AM | Reply | Permalink
I think this is why my feathers got so ruffled when Michael referred to ObamaOprah in another post.
aMike
March 23, 2007 8:26 AM | Reply | Permalink
Too much of organized religion and their flunkies has become an organized racket
with money as the prime objective.
March 23, 2007 9:22 AM | Reply | Permalink
Christianity today is, at it's core, big business.
He is smart enough and wise enough to use the trustworthiness he has developed over the years with those who look up to him and respect his opinion. This has allowed him to build this vast media empire. He has evolved, consciously I believe, into a combination Sam Walton/Oprah Winfrey for the fundamentalist wing of Christianity.
This is where, I think, things can begin to get a little dangerous. Dobson has been smart enough to realize that the credibility he has now with his followers, established through years of completely non-political advice, can now be exploited in a very real way in the political arena. It makes one wonder if there might not be a Jim Jones type quality to how his followers view him. I'm not trying to say that Dobson is another Jim Jones, but Jones did establish a degree of legitimacy within the community and in mainstream circles at the time. He was courted by politicians and feted withing the local media. Yet there was a dangerous invisible undercurrent that existed around him. But the fact that he was legitimized in mainstream circles allowed that to be suppressed. In the end, we know things unraveled very tragically for those who followed him.
Dobson is a true political force to be reckoned with. His word and advice is Gospel to millions of fundamentalist Christians. His influence is felt in every nook and cranny of this country. He could marshal, through a simple statement, millions of loyal and unquestioning followers to undertake almost any task. I personally know of a number of friends and family who would take his direction quite seriously.
That is what makes me a little fearful of his potential power over our political discourse.
And this description of Dobson struck me as a perfect composite of another powerful political leader who espouses a lot of the same views. Someone who seems to take pride in going against the grain, contrary to all facts and evidence. Someone who takes pleasure in in his hubris.Unfortunately, that other person resides at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.
March 23, 2007 9:26 AM | Reply | Permalink
Dobson's another bible-bearing blankety-blanking politician, and the best service he could do for humanity is, well...use your imagination, there.
Focus on the Right-Wing Bible-Jesus may have its' avid viewers, but I eschew such digital Kool-aid in favor of a 'think for yourself' approach to life, which also accordingly means I 'own' my mistakes rather than emulating those of other people. In english, even if you screw up in life, you did it sort of 'Elvis' style, you did it YOUR way, rather than the Focus On the Church Revenue Stream officially advocated method. What? Dobson wants to turn the country into a sanctified breeding farm? No thanks, there, raise your own damn kids and keep em off my porch with their religious propaganda, please.
I'd like to see Dobson's holier-than-though august institution of the First Church of The Digital Communal publicly audited on a weekly(hourly? No, that's dreaming) basis, so as to ensure FULL public transparency of EVERY plug nickel that lands in their collection plate, either the brass or digital version. Something's rotten in Denmark with that entire outfit and it's got a Jesus(R) trademark stamped on it(printed in Taiwan)....
March 23, 2007 9:43 AM | Reply | Permalink
Actually, when you say that Christianity at its core is a business, you are saying that the faith is equal to various incorporated artificial entities. That is false.
Christianity is a spiritually based way of life with faith in God and teaching wisdom on relating to God and to others. That is what it is, and until the transformation or end of this fallen world, that is what it shall be among the people who are Christians.
March 24, 2007 11:29 AM | Reply | Permalink
...he stressed that it’s never too late to reverse course and become a “secondary virgin.”
Grover Norquist is now offering the availability of "secondary virginity" to politicians. By publicly confessing an adulterous affair to Dobson, Newt Gingrich seems to be the first one to avail himself of this opportunity.
As Bruce Reed of Slate opined:
War does not determine who is right - only who is left. Bertrand Russell
March 24, 2007 2:18 PM | Reply | Permalink
I couldn't read Grover's offer; can you tell me how much he's charging for this "secondary virginity"?
Does this work like the Catholics who go to confession to have the slate wiped clean?
Lets see, we go to Grover, or is it Dobson?, he hears our confession, and our virginity gets reinstated when do our penance, which is a "donation".
March 25, 2007 5:26 AM | Reply | Permalink
From a financial perspective, the operations of Focus on the Family are a lot more transparent than other so-called faith-based groups. Dr. Dobson provides Focus on the Family's annual reports and 990s IRS filings on the Focus website.
To his credit, Dobson refrains from making the kind of untoward remarks about other people's beliefs that the Rev. Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson are so famous for.
On the other hand, Dr. Dobson treated Squarepants Spongebob very unfairly, imo.
March 25, 2007 10:48 AM | Reply | Permalink
John, apparently it involves making the "right promises". With Grover, that would mean no new taxes and rolling back the ones already on the books.
Poof-adulterous affair all gone. Now, wasn't that easy?
War does not determine who is right - only who is left. Bertrand Russell
March 25, 2007 7:31 PM | Reply | Permalink
I guess the Government's expenses never go up; no increase in labor/benefits costs, no increase in energy costs, no increase in the price of pencils, paper, gasoline, autos, defense, maintenance. Of course the remedy for all that is "CUT COSTS."
After 3 years on the job and no raise, I can now afford only half a loaf of bread; I gave up air conditioning, and we use electricity only 12 hours a day, my car, my health care and life insurance, are all gone, we eat only one meal a day; and so I went to my boss and asked again for a raise, and again, he replied "CUT COSTS."
March 26, 2007 7:02 AM | Reply | Permalink
Dan, you held your own pretty good on Michael Medved's Radio program yesterday. Good show.
March 29, 2007 6:56 AM | Reply | Permalink