Nelson Polsby, 1934-2007

Nelson Polsby, one of the giants of American political science, died Tuesday in his home in Berkeley, California.

If you ever took an intro to American political science class, odds are that you read his work or bought one of the 11 editions of his classic, Presidential Elections, which he co-wrote with his equally influential colleague, Aaron Wildavsky.

Personally, I owe my own foray into political science – and my doctorate -- to Nelson. His book, Political Innovation, was a shaping influence on my own work on partisan change; my supervisor had his doctoral studies supervised by Nelson; and when it came time for my own doctoral exam, Nelson was my outside examiner.

Now, the oral exam – or viva voce – at Oxford is the ultimate hurdle in the long process of getting a doctorate. It’s the final defense of what you have written.

In preparation, I secluded myself at my college for a week, reviewing every possible piece of literature – as well as my dissertation. When it came time for my exam, I put on the obligatory “sub-fusc” dress – a black gown, white tie, and black suit (think a grown up Harry Potter), and made my way to the exam.

The internal examiner also was in the sub-fusc get-up, and we waited for Nelson. After a few minutes, Nelson came in. A large man, he was wearing worn out corduroys, heavily broken in topsiders, and an equally comfortable cardigan sweater. He plopped himself on the couch, and then the Oxford examiner said, “Nelson, you are supposed to be wearing sub-fusc.” To which, he responded, “I’m from Berkeley. You’re lucky I’m wearing shoes.”

Nelson was a great wit, conversationalist, and provocateur -- with intense academic rigor. When it came time for him to give his visiting professorship lecture at Oxford, Nelson argued that the single biggest variable to explain postwar American politics was air-conditioning (an argument he expanded in the book How Congress Evolves).

The death of Nelson Polsby, then, is a personal and academic loss, and I am afraid that it also marks the passing of a dwindling breed: the publicly-engaged political scientist.

As Kevin Mattson argued about the history profession in the last issue of Democracy is also true for political scientists: The field has devolved into intramural, technical arguments of little relevance to anyone outside of the field. Modeling City Council voting in 19th century Philadelphia may be interesting or even skillful, but it tells us little about the operation, strength, and promise of our democratic institutions. And even if there were insights gained from one’s scholarly work, there is little incentive to write or promote it for an elite or general audience.

Nelson was a political scientist who cared about politics. He studied it as it was practiced, offered his opinions, and got involved in the rough-and-tumble of public debate. His work had direct relevance on the issues of the day, and he helped journalists make sense of what was happening around them. Unfortunately, there are very few political scientists left with a comparable interest in and impact on national politics.

I would end this by wishing that Nelson should “rest in peace,” but as one of Nelson’s former students (and one of my wisest teachers) put it to me the other day, “no one who knew him ever saw him ‘at peace’.” And that’s why he was such a great teacher, scholar, and contributor to public life.


Comments (5)

The death of Nelson Polsby, then, is a personal and academic loss, and I am afraid that it also marks the passing of a dwindling breed: the publicly-engaged political scientist.

Being from Virginia (but not being very political science-savvy), I wonder what you think about Larry Sabato in that regard. (Obviously, even if he does meet your criteria as a "publicly-engaged political scientist", one example does not in any way detract from it being a dwindling breed.)

I know you want Baer's opinion but I think Sabato should be held in quite high regard. I constantly ran into his books and articles during college and then afterwards, as a cub reporter at a local alt-weekly with zero influence, always found Sabato willing to take my calls and sometimes engage in long discussions. He thoughts his ideas were important enough to explain to a nobody and I'll always appreciate that.

thosethingswesay.blogspot.com

Stop the presses! CNN, MSNBC, Fox News and countless others have the real story that we need to attend to:

Anna Nicole Smith is dead and there's a shit-load of innuendo that we all need to glom over, because we don't want to glom over the REAL scandals in our country!

How many of our bravest are dead? There is no mystery about HOW they died. The mystery for those who care is WHY are they dead?

In the mean time, we wring our hand about a pathetic former Playboy Bunny who slurred her speach for the last year and is now dead. Why? How could it happen? But most important: Who will get her billions?

Jan Knaus

avatar

How must Jayne Mansfield feel to hear another blonde compoared to Marilyn Monroe?

www.fakeconsultant.blogspot.com

I'm sure Kenneth Baer is speaking from the urgency of the heart, but he neglects to contribute anything to the political discussion here. Even a routine obit would say something about the man's ideas and speculate on their pertinence to pressing issues now.

I'm sure the man had a cuddly dress style and deserves all sorts of glorious adjectives, but it's a pointless post. It leaves only the impression, I hope mistakenly, that the poster is merely paying his dues to other insiders who might be reading. I hate to be rude on the occasion of a death, but I don't come here for that, and I get it all too often already with America Abroad.

John

http://www.haberarts.com/

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


August 18-22

Book Cover

September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address