The Collapse of Tax Cut Politics

You can check out Progressive States rundown of progressive successes in the states on Tuesday, but I want to focus on one key area-- the humiliating collapse of the tax cut politics promoted in the states by people like Grover Norquist. 

While it got little national coverage, for those concerned about health care and education, the number one issue in the states this year was defeating the so called "TAxpayer Bill Of Rights" (TABOR) initiatives. A version of TABOR passed in the early 90s had crippled education and health care budgets in Colorado until it was partially repealed last year and the rightwing had hoped to have TABOR on ballots across the country. 

Their plan began to fall apart earlier this year when progressives highlighted the fraud in signature collecting in multiple states and had them thrown off the ballot in Michigan, Montana, Nevada, Oklahoma and Missouri.

And then on Tuesday, voters in Maine, Nebraska and Oregon finished the job in voting down the remaining TABOR initiatives left. (See these Progressive States' talking points on TABOR distributed to legislators and advocates early in the year and some of the reasons voters rejected them).  In addition, an initiative to repeal Washington's state estate tax was also rejected by voters, while Oregon and South Dakota rejected other significant tax reduction initiatives.

The media may try to spin this election as only about Iraq or simple disenchantment with Bush, but the rejection by voters of tax revolt politics-- a core ideological base of the whole Reaganite agenda from its birth -- is a clear message that modern conservatism had run seriously into the ditch and it's not clear what will pull them out.  Their coalitions are fraying and it's not clear what will hold many of their folks together without the glue of tax cut politics.

So yes, this was a very ideological election and a clear victory for progressives, which they can build on during the policy debates to come.


Comments (6)

avatar

Katrina killed tax cuts politics.

Oh sure, not single-handed. It was brewing. But it probably was the catalyst.

I think it taught a lot of Americans that low taxes are nice but that a functionnal government is even better, and sometimes a matter of life and death.

No, you can't have your own facts!

I like to challenge my tax-cut friends by asking how often they fix the potholes on the roads and streets they drive, which night of the week they volunteer to tutor all the homeschooled kids on their block, for crime patrols and fire protection in their neighborhood, to fight the wars they support, etc. It doesn't take long before they compel themselves into defending an ethic of every-man-for-himself, or else they get the point.

It doesn't take long before they compel themselves into defending an ethic of every-man-for-himself, or else they get the point.

How many take the first course?  (Dead enders.) 

If I had a lot of money, I'd have made up a bunch of bumper stickers that read "Pave Your Own Damn Roads - Vote Republican". But...maybe that would be too cerebral to get the message across.

avatar

Opinion polls have consistently shown that most people care less about tax cuts than other issues. But "most people" aren't the ones who decide elections usually.  Ideologues play a disproportionate role in politics as they are the ones who are most motivated to go out and vote.  And my guess is that we have not seen the end of tax cuts as a tool to motivate the conservative base of the GOP. 

avatar

A cursory read of taxes - mostly excise and tariffs - imposed by goverments through the centuries reveals that the costs of wars prompted most of them: The Napoleonic Wars (Britain); The French and Indian Wars (Brit. on the colonies); the Civil War; the War of 1812; WWI, to name a few.

Those who object to taxes should probably begin their crusade by objecting to war.

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Claire Wilcox



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address