TPMCafe
« The Uninsured Class | Home | Full Court Propaganda Press »

The Lord Has Given, The Lord Has Taken - Bless be the Lord's Name?

user-pic

Eulogy for Michael Etzioni (1967-2006)

If you broke my knee caps, both of them; gouged out my eyes; and tore my heart out with your bare hands—it would pain me much less. Who is cruel enough to take this loving son, in the prime of his life, from his aging, ailing father? Who would tear a doting husband out of the arms of his loving wife? Deny a one year old son, the love of his father, and-- leave behind an infant to be born-- who will be unable to see his father even once? Who would take from four brothers, scores of other family members, and a legion of friends—their close and dear companion?

My wife tells me not to curse God. I do not. I believe in an almighty God who created the universe and gives it meaning. I must admit, though, that I sometimes am consumed by doubts. Where was that God in the killing fields of Cambodia? Why is he not shining his face on the people of Baghdad or Darfur? Above all, as a young Jewish child, born in Germany and who lived there during the Nazi’s takeover, I failed to see Him during the Holocaust.

My faith, to which I do hold on, is being tested to the point that I wonder whether my life was cut out of a page of the book of Job. First, a good part of my extended family was exterminated in the concentration camps. Then Minerva, my wife, the mother of Mike and Dari and Benjamin, was taken from us without warning, at the prime of her life. She was as outgoing, giving, and as loved as Mike was.

Then Mike was taken from us in early hours of August 24, 2006, without warning or preparations.

Mike was a son no father could ask for any better. Mike called me several times a week, often a day. When I would call him, and ask “is now it a good time?” Mike’s standard answer was “for you, aba, always”. Mike announced he and I had a ‘treaty’ that I would not go to countries on the State Department’s unsafe nations list. He made an exception for Israel. When I was invited to give a lecture in Colombia, Mike was on my case, urging, pleading, and demanding that I not go. When I got a new medication, Mike rushed to the Internet to study it and to warn me (which no one else did) that I must cease eating grapefruits. Often Mike called to ensure that a move he was planning to make in his personal or professional life might not somehow trouble the other person, undermine their position, or violate their confidence. And Mike called again and again “just to tell you, aba, that I love you very much”.

No father can ask for better.

Mike was a father no child could ask for any better. No one I know looked forward more to becoming a parent—several times over. Mike was a happy person but nothing came close to making him happier and prouder then when Lainie gave him Max in 2005 and—a year later – that another one was to follow. Mike used to talk to me about the news from the Middle East, development at his work place and among his friends and much else. But once Max was born, half of the time he was regaling me with the wonders of his son who took a step on his own! Who listened to a count on Sesame Street from one to five, and suddenly added—six! Who found a box that suited his size and used it as a table for his meal. And so on and on. A day Mike had to leave for work before Max was up or return after he was a sleep, was a painful day. On the day before Mike died, he got up early to play with Max and put him on the picture phone for me, to share his joy.

Dari, Mike’s brother, reminded us all how passionately Mike loved to play golf. He started playing rather poorly but worked hard at it, until he played a fair game. Above all, he much enjoyed being out there, with his good friends, hitting balls. That is, until Max was born. Mike dropped golf within a day, explaining that parenting was much more important. He never once complained or saw himself as a martyr.
All children should be so wanted. All children should be so loved. No child should have his father withdrawn so cruelly.

No spouse could ask for a better partner. In all the years Mike and Lainie were together, I never heard Mike say a bad word about his wife. He invariably declared that whatever plans were going to be made “I check with Lainie”. He sought to protect her from need, should anything happen to him, and did so very well indeed. His happiest years were those when he was married, and among those—once Lainie was expecting – Mike could not contain his joy.

No friend had a more loyal friend . Mike was forever fussing about his friends. If he was not crazy about the men several of his women friends dated, he set out --and several times succeeded-- to help them do better. If he was not keen about the job one of his friends held, he tried to help her find a better position. He had a keen ear for what was troubling people and a natural talent in reaching out and helping people cope with whatever besieged them.
* * *
Many wonder what happened. Medical explanations are sure to follow. However, I see a deeper cause: MIKE’S HEART BEAT FOR EVERYONE ELSE UNTIL NO BEAT WAS LEFT FOR HIMSELF.

Those who knew Mike can post comments at this website.


19 Comments

| Leave a comment

Dear Amitai,

I am so sorry for your loss.

-- Ned

Thanks for sharing this Amitai. I'm so, so sorry for your loss.

I just called my own son. I'll call my dad tonight.

Nothing I can imagine would be harder to bear.  My thoughts, my tears are yours.

My deepest condolences, Amitai.

Parents should never have to bury their children. This is very cruel. I am so sorry.

How terrible for you. I'm very sorry. But this is what we have to live with, isn't it? Get past the anger, Amitai. This is it.

What tragic news.  He was far too young to be taken.  My deepest condolences to you and your family Mr. Etzioni.

I probably understand more than most. I face the possibilty of the same tragedy every single day. I am so sorry for you.

Your description of the pain touches me deeply. I feel it every time I look into my poor sick son's eyes.

I don't know why people say religion gives solace. Believing in a God that could do this leaves people with only bewilderment, it appears to me.

As an atheist, I have no one to be angry with. It's a very cold feeling but it has to be better than wondering why God would do this.

Best wishes as your family learns to live without him.

Writing A Grief Observed as "a defense against total collapse, a safety valve," he [C.S.Lewis] came to recognize that "bereavement is a universal and integral part of our experience of love."

Lewis became a Christian following years of not believing. His wife, the poet Joy Davidman, was Jewish.  In "A Grief Observed" Lewis writes about her death, his anguish, his sense of God's absence, how grief feels.  Chapter One begins with:

No one ever told me that grief felt so like fear. I am not afraid, but the sensation is like being afraid. The same fluttering in the stomach, the same restlessness, the yawning. I keep on swallowing.

Shalom.

Eternal memory. Sadness shared is divided; happiness shared is multiplied.
--
Howard

MIKE’S HEART BEAT FOR EVERYONE ELSE UNTIL NO BEAT WAS LEFT FOR HIMSELF.

There is a terrible beauty in this.

Blessed be.

Dear Prof. Etzioni,

I pray that your love for your son, and his for you, will transcend your sorrow.

Pob bendith i chi.

A father should not have to bury his son. And without warning, too. This is unutterably sad.

I am very sorry to read of your terrible loss.

That's a stunningly apt description; thanks.

[hugs]

A beautifully written post. This is so tragic. I'm very sorry for your loss.

Sir, I am so very sorry for your lost. I don't know what it's like to lose a son or daughter but I can only imagine. I will pray for you and ask God to see you through with this unbearable pain. Keep your faith. God Bless You

My deepest condolences to you and your entire family on your loss.  I pray you find comfort in your time of grief. 

I was priveleged to have this man as my best friend. A friendship that spanned 20 years beginning while we were both teenagers at the University of Michigan. Mike was an excellent human being, father, husband, son, brother and (especially to me) friend. He was a prince and I loved him.

To write about him now sounds like a eulogistic cliche, yet everything said about him is true. Mike was our crown jewel.

During the eulogy I gave for him, I tried to bring a little peace to his family and perhaps even a laugh and a tear. It was meant to help soothe the 600+ at the service with a few shared warm moments and perhaps some communal tears.

What I did not address was, "why?" How could this happen to this particular man? I believe in God. Life has programmed me to believe that this happened for a reason. What reason? The inability to understand this is what leads me to believe there must be more out there. We just can't see or understand it. Similar to a 2 dimmensional being trying to understand a 3rd dimmension. It is beyond comprehension. Think of the dog that you leave home before you go to work for the first time. That dog does not know you are coming back and he will cry and whimper as you walk out the door. You, however are not upset, because you know you will see him soon. His eternity is your 8 hours. You see, you have an understanding, the dog can't fathom. We understand time in a way that animals can't. And perhaps Mike understands time in a way that we can't.

What might be our next dimmension, or heaven, if you will? The best explanation (and the one that soothes my own soul the most) is that Michael can see us (and be with us). I have certainly felt his presence. He is happy and smiling and does not feel time like we do. We will all be with him again and are with him now. He can see us young and old all at the same time.

It is our lack of understanding of this that causes grief. When a loved one leaves for 10 minutes to drive to the store, we say goodby and may not miss him. When he leaves for a month, we will miss him, but are comforted by knowing we will see him soon. If gone for a year, say overseas, we may feel some pain about the length of his departure. However, deep sadness and grief come about when we feel the departure is permanent. What if it isn't permanent? What if this is only a trip to the store, in the grand scheme of time, but we lack the understanding to know that?

Could Michael be at peace because he now understands the questions we have posed since the beginning of time? He now understands that our human life spans the flash of a bulb. We on earth are still in that flash and that is all we know. And he can now see the entire flash from outside and inside and understands what it means in comparison to eternity.

We may not have the understanding, but we have the ability for faith. And faith tells me, Mike just went to the store and we will meet again.

Until then, my dear friend, I will miss you. A piece of me went with you and I am no longer whole. You were part of my identity and my self. I feel that bottomless pit when I try to imagine life without you in 5 years, 10 years, 20 years. I understand how someone could be angry in my shoes, but I will have faith (something I learned from you) and wait for us to meet again.

You were all very lucky to have Mike.

Perhaps he is at peace because, he knows how lucky he was to have all of you.

[hugs]

Thank you.

CSPAN junkies visit http://spannerbackup.ipbhost.com

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »



Book Club Calendar


This Week

Blood and Politics: The History of the White Nationalist Movement from the Margins to the Mainstream, Leonard Zeskind

Next Week

Henry Waxman, The Waxman Report: How Congress Really Works

July 13-17

Justin Fox, The Myth of the Rational Market: A History of Risk, Reward, and Delusion on Wall Street

July 27-31

Plenty Enough Suck To Go Around, Cheryl Wagner

« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Kyle Krahel-Frolander



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address