Something's Happening Here
Bruce Springsteen, Green Day, Neil Young, Audio Slave, Pink (If you haven’t seen the concert video of her song “Dear Mr. President, by all means check it out. It’s all over the web. Trust me, it’s better than Stephen Colbert at the correspondents’ dinner.), Dixie Chicks, Pearl Jam…David Sirota.
David Sirota? Absolutely. David has written an album of protest songs. It’s called Hostile Takeover. And a fine album it is. You should buy it, read it and, hopefully, get as indignant and fired up as David is. The songs are great. It’s a concept album, so they work together nicely too.
But as Elizabeth Warren and others have pointed out, there is a problem.
The problem is not enough protest movement to go with these great “albums.” That’s not a criticism of David’s book. Each chapter has solutions as well as a critique. But still, we are all searching for the critical mass that gives coherence and power to addressing the problems that David skillfully describes. Unlike the 60’s, when stars and celebrities like Harry Belafonte, James Baldwin, Peter, Paul and Mary, Joan Baez, Marion Anderson, and others were drawn to the movement, it’s now almost like it's the celebrities who are trying to create the movement.
Of course social movements are unpredictable. Almost by definition they come out of nowhere—even when they are the product of quite a lot of planning as with the Montgomery Bus Boycott. These days we see this illustrated with the stunning—if still yet to become focused—demonstrations by immigrants.
So I won’t be surprised if I am surprised by some mass resistance that comes out of the blue. And when it does, it will give politicians and pundits alike something to respond to instead of the other way around.
In that spirit, I’d also like to take the opportunity of plugging David’s book to do a little pump priming. Here’s a concrete suggestion: David—please lobby for my idea of “Fight-Back Debt Counseling Centers.” Your appearance at AFL-CIO headquarters for your official book launch at 7:00 PM on Tuesday, May 9 would be an especially appropriate place to do so.
What’s a Fight-Back Debt Counseling Center? Well, I think that’s something TPMcafé readers and others can work together to flesh out. But as I roughly envision them, they would be somewhat like the draft counseling centers that played such a crucial role in building opposition to the war in Viet Nam. Trained counselors would give advice to clients about their debt burdens and how to cope with them. They would help individuals cope with overbearing collection agencies and credit card companies who have broken even their own rules in applying their ever expanding and ever more draconian menu of late fees, penalties, escalating interest rates etc.
But they would do more than that—much more. Fight Back Debt Counseling Centers would organize the unorganized and empower the powerless. They would litigate and demonstrate. They would serve to overcome the isolation that people feel—the sense that “I-am-all-alone,” in my fight with Citibank, the bankruptcy court or whoever. I think that sense is broader and deeper than we realize. My guess is that there isn’t an hour that goes by that scores if not hundreds of Americans aren’t staring at a credit card bill or their student loan statement or, for that matter, their paycheck, poised for the kind of epiphany that David describes when being jerked around by an airline at the beginning of Hostile Takeover.
Why bring this up at the AFL-CIO? Two reasons. First, if unions aren’t about bringing together the individually abused into a collective force for—dare I use the expression, the common good—then who the heck is? And as with traditional, “20th century,” workplace questions, 21st century debt is a great equalizer. It is an issue around which white, black, brown, men, women, GLBT, fundamentalist Baptists, Roman Catholics, latte drinking, crushed by student loans young Episcopalians and older citizens whose pensions just got cut in half can all unite. It also lends itself to problem-solving and hope, not just fear and anger. And unions more than any other institution have the know-how, the resources and the infrastructure, including union halls and union members, to make this happen.
The second reason is that the AFL-CIO has something else. It has the Union Privilege Credit card. With some not-that-far-out-of-the-box thinking, Union Privilege can put together a genuinely attractive and non-profit (or very low profit), package of debt consolidation financing and traditional credit counseling that can work hand-in-hand with the more political and activist fight-back aspect of the Fight-Back Debt Counseling Centers.
Like Bruce’s song in New Orleans says, time to stand up together to get the man to “pay-me-my-money down.” If not now, when?
Bottom line—if this idea makes sense to you, terrific, let’s refine it. If it doesn’t, that’s fine too. Let’s develop some alternatives around taxes, jobs and the other issues David describes. The important thing is let’s treat Hostile Takeover as a catalyst for translating alienation and isolation into organizing and action.











Comments (4)
Wednesday, May 03, 2006
12:05:29
Nice piece. But is the answer "joining in" or is it "standing one's ground"? We have all been chosen if you will "to be" part in a group. I used to hate it but now I love it. I hope that one day you will too.
When you figure it out come see me. I don’t think I have long before they come and shut me down. But I will be ready for them.
May 3, 2006 9:11 AM | Reply | Permalink
Although the message isn't necessarily accurate, Pearl Jam's new self-titled album is astonishingly great. No doubt they are one of the top three or four rock bands of all-time (in my opinion of course).
May 3, 2006 9:16 AM | Reply | Permalink
Oh, Oh, Frank- now you've done it!
You see, this entire idea is terroristic to the Bush Regime.
When our instruction for national sacrifice after 9/11 was to go shopping, we Americans took that to heart as our national duty. We accumulated all sorts of unneeded junk in order to do that. It became more of a lifestyle than we could deal with.
Add to that the squandering of the governmental resources and the corporatization of the nation and we gerbils in the cage have to run even faster, be even more oblivious to what's happening just to exist from month to month.
So here's where the terrorism creeps in-
Use the debt-counseling centers to help change people's lifestyle, use the credit-card vehicle to pay off those 30% interest rate credit cards and their late payment double jeopardy rules and the the credit industry begins to collapse. Hell, even issue a different card from the Union as a sponsor of the program with a point higher rate to help fund the project. You just might convince a lot of socially conscious people to switch- creating that amorphous but condensing cloud of a social movement.
And that would be bad for "the economy"- at least the one that has been shaped and molded by this administration, their lobbyists and their employees our legislators.
I'd bet you end up on all sorts of lists then. ;<)
Alphonse ( Al ) Kada
May 3, 2006 9:48 AM | Reply | Permalink
This is an interesting idea. Looks like I'm still dodging the bankruptcy bullet, so I suppose I won't be needing the services of a counseling/advocacy group anytime soon. But encouraging the Union to use it's credit infrastructure to this end is intriguing - my debts are all at low interest rates and hopefully will stay that way, but I would consider such an offer for the political ramifications, if it came my way.
May 3, 2006 12:56 PM | Reply | Permalink