Traffic
Readers may recall that I did a post back in late October disparaging the traffic-centric nature of the Virginia gubernatorial election. Well, the truth of the matter is that I hadn't driven in Virginia for a while when I wrote that. This afternoon, I took a trip to the Trader Joe's in Fall's Church and holy shit is there a big traffic problem in Northern Virginia. Considering that this was a totally non-rush-hour excursion, the experience left me sobered and frightened as to what regular commuters living in the area must experience. So, by all means, make traffic the top issue in statewide politics.
As it happens, the Gods of Zipcar gave me a Prius this time around, which was my first experience driving a hybrid. It's pretty freaky. The car has an "on" button, like it's a TV, you don't turn a key in the ignition, the gearshift is totally unorthodox, and I couldn't figore out how to open the trunk. Generally speaking, that's probably the future, especially if traffic stays that bad, since it really uses almost no gas as long as your stuck going very slowly all the time.











Comments (14)
Indeed. It is a rare instance that I've pulled onto 66 from an Arlington on-ramp and not ended up in bumper to bumper traffic - time of day doesn't matter. It's generally not an issue for me, though - I live within walking distance of the orange line (and work at Farragut), and the surface streets in Arlington are just fine.
But if I actually had to go to Bailey's Crossroads on a regular basis? Or was one of those poor souls with a job out in Tyson's/Reston? Postal, I think.
I think better mass transit should be more than part of the solution - it needs to be the centerpiece. There simply isn't enough land left to pave over. But more paving has to to be the case, in some places (but not I-66 inside the beltway - it simply moves the bottleneck to the Roosevelt).
December 18, 2005 7:40 AM | Reply | Permalink
Try this: pretend you have kids that you want in a better school district than DC; find the closest-in town in Virginia where you can afford a home (I'm betting Manassas); drive out there one weekend and get a hotel room; spend a week commuting to your job. Keep track of how many hours of your life it uses up, how much it costs, and what it does to your blood pressure. Now decide what issue will be most important to you in the next election.
Note, however, that the experienced NOVA commuters are ambivalent about road and mass transit construction. We know that doing anything will mess us up with construction delays for years. I live in Haymarket, just north of where Disney's failure in the 90's has now resulted in the construction of 5,000 McMansions. I've come to realize that there is literally no solution to the problem that will have a positive effect before I retire.
December 18, 2005 10:45 AM | Reply | Permalink
First, there is more to Virginia than the DC suburbs, endless as they may seem. This is different from Maryland, where the 'burbs seem to have critical mass in statewide elections. While it may be true that Kaine's victory owes a lot to gains in the suburbs, Dems can't win the state back without making a dent in the Republican strongholds around Richmond, the Tidewater, and the Shenandoah Valley.
Second, I have to take issue with the point about mass transit. The subway system is excellent, actually reaches the suburbs where the commuters live, and cost a hell of a lot of federal money. The emphasis needs to be on more incentives for commuters to use it. If I were king, I'd have all private vehicles entering the "Pink Zone" (borrowed from Italy, where they do this) of the Mall, K Street, and Georgetown be required to park at the perimeter and walk. It's good for everyone. And, eliminate parking at the Federal buildings (unless you're Asst. Secy. level or get an exemption due to handicap or something).
Third, Prius is an early form of a transforming technology. There are still a lot of rough edges. Your rental car people should have showed you how to use the vehicle!
December 18, 2005 10:46 AM | Reply | Permalink
My 'rents moved us down to Northern VA back in the late 60s and save for college I've lived here ever since. Things are very, very bad, as in reaching the critical mass stage. We have reached the tipping point where most folks in Fairfax, Arlington, Falls Church and Alexandria know that there's no more roads to build and that the current metrorail system is reaching Tokyo desity in the rush hours.
So it's not simply a matter of encouraging folks to use mass transit! They are when they can. Parking lots at Vienna and Dunn Loring stops on the Orange line are full by 7:30 or so and I suspect that is also the case at West Falls Church. Trains also back up in the mornings as there's only one two track tunnel to get you from VA to DC on either the Orange or Blue lines (The Yellow line has a separate bridge across the Potomac). It's a tinker toy subway for what is now a huge city.
Folks who claim they cannot afford to live any closer than Mannassas are in denial about choices made. They could afford to live closer to work but insist upon either new construction or are unwilling to settle for a condo or townhouse closer in. Folks living in Gainsville literally must have a hole in their head -- the traffic jams out there begin at 6:00 am. Me? I saved up and was able to afford a 40 year old SFM in Fairfax in a school district that is pretty good but not the best so it was 60,000 less than the houses behind it that are in the primo high school district.
Unfortunately however instead of actually having the political courage to stand up to the folks downstate who do not wish to allow us to build the infrastructure we realy need, cockamaime schemes are being hatched. HOT lanes are a boondoggle that will be a nightmare for generations to come. Maybe, I hope and pray that enough politicans and citizens will wake up and smell the coffee -- it's not a free lunch.
December 18, 2005 12:50 PM | Reply | Permalink
Yikes didn't know it would beltch out the comment without paragraph breaks!
My 'rents moved us down to Northern VA back in the late 60s and save for college I've lived here ever since. Things are very, very bad, as in reaching the critical mass stage. We have reached the tipping point where most folks in Fairfax, Arlington, Falls Church and Alexandria know that there's no more roads to build and that the current metrorail system is reaching Tokyo desity in the rush hours.
So it's not simply a matter of encouraging folks to use mass transit! They are when they can. Parking lots at Vienna and Dunn Loring stops on the Orange line are full by 7:30 or so and I suspect that is also the case at West Falls Church. Trains also back up in the mornings as there's only one two track tunnel to get you from VA to DC on either the Orange or Blue lines (The Yellow line has a separate bridge across the Potomac). It's a tinker toy subway for what is now a huge city.
Folks who claim they cannot afford to live any closer than Mannassas are in denial about choices made. They could afford to live closer to work but insist upon either new construction or are unwilling to settle for a condo or townhouse closer in. Folks living in Gainsville literally must have a hole in their head -- the traffic jams out there begin at 6:00 am. Me? I saved up and was able to afford a 40 year old SFM in Fairfax in a school district that is pretty good but not the best so it was 60,000 less than the houses behind it that are in the primo high school district.
Unfortunately however instead of actually having the political courage to stand up to the folks downstate who do not wish to allow us to build the infrastructure we realy need, cockamaime schemes are being hatched. HOT lanes are a boondoggle that will be a nightmare for generations to come. Maybe, I hope and pray that enough politicans and citizens will wake up and smell the coffee -- it's not a free lunch.
December 18, 2005 12:53 PM | Reply | Permalink
Matt, welcome to the Holy Church of Prius!
I'm heading back for the US sometimes next year and that thing is the TOP thing on my shopping list when I arrive.
December 18, 2005 12:55 PM | Reply | Permalink
"This afternoon, I took a trip to the Trader Joe's in Fall's Church and holy shit is there a big traffic problem in Northern Virginia. Considering that this was a totally non-rush-hour excursion, the experience left me sobered and frightened as to what regular commuters living in the area must experience. So, by all means, make traffic the top issue in statewide politics."
Welcome to suburban, blue state America in the early twenty-first century. I haven't spend any amount of time in northern Virginia since the mid 1990s (when my parents lived briefly and for no especially good reason in Jackie O horse country), but rush hour traffic was already quite preposterous in the early part of that decade (my friend and I drove to college in New York from the west coast, and it was the only particularly nightmarish leg of the trip...it took hours to get through Virginia, and I think we almost gave up going to college and stopped for good in Maryland).
Some places are even worse today. Something like the whole of southern California is a parking lot most hours of the day and night now, and as they have found you really can't build your way out of this problem. We need policies that encourage telecommuting, more rail and bus-only lanes. But barring a kind of peak oil catastrophe the suburban dream might just prefer to migrate to other areas. Increasingly, the inner suburbs are becoming enclaves for rich, liberalish people, and the folks with the real nightmare commutes tend to be exurbanites. One suspects many of them would be as comfortable living outside Reno or Tucson as living in Riverside County.
December 18, 2005 12:56 PM | Reply | Permalink
The subway system ... actually reaches the suburbs where the commuters live
No, it doesn't, it barely clears the Beltway. Driving in to Vienna is about the worst commute my wife or I have, on days that we have to be there or all the way downtown. Also, most of the time the parking at the Vienna Metro station is a real problem; you have to get there by about 6:00am to get a space. I'm told that a new parking garage has temporarily reduced that need, but it's certainly the case that the need will grow to exceed the capacity. Eventually, of course, there won't be room for any more garages.December 18, 2005 1:21 PM | Reply | Permalink
Many American subway systems -- Metro and BART, for example -- are not true subways, but small-scale commuter-rail systems. If you compare them to the system in Paris, say, you just want to cry. Building a real network involves building more than a few lines.
December 18, 2005 9:31 PM | Reply | Permalink
I work in Farragut as well, Matt, and I live in Reisterstown, Maryland, 50 miles from the job. My daily commute is car 20 miles to Halethorpe MARC rail to Union Station (31 miles, 30-45 minutes) and Red Line from Union Station to Farragut. Ranges from 90 minutes to 2 hours, depending. I would rather be me than you, though.
No way would I live in Virginia, that hellhole of impossible obscene traffic, unless I were a millionaire and could afford a three bedroom house w/in 1000 yards of a Metro station. My father in law lives in Alexandria away from the Metro and works in Ballston; I suspect crack or crystal meth must be to blame. Real estate prices drive these matters as well.
Maryland is in generally better shape; it was friendlier to the Metro from the beginning and provides excellent service (with a few hiccups) on the MARC train as well, sparing probably 35,000 cars a day on or near I-95 all the way to Baltimore or points northwest. Six spokes of the Metro enter Maryland all the way to the Beltway or beyond; two and a half enter Virginia (the toy-pony Yellow Line is almost superfluous and enjoys low ridership except as a duplicate of the Blue or Green lines when it shares tracks.) The NE Corridor/Penn MARC line, which I take daily, is electrified and it shows, Virginia's rail lines are diesel and have poor running times (and very limited service.) Maryland has some serious traffic problems but taking real strides to improve matters, including a possible radial light rail line inside Maryland below the Beltway. Traffic will be an issue in the upcoming governor's race in Maryland but will be dwarfed by taxes, crime, education and gambling.
The roads in Virginia are too narrow and far too few, the Potomac needs another three bridges, the Metro needs to hit Seven Corners, Bailey's Crossroads, Tysons Corner including a rail link from Maryland directly into Virginia. So much money in Virginia, so little willingness to solve problems.
Southern-fried traffic planning brought Virginia a fun commute. It is sort of like a wealthy version of a Mexican border colonia; instead of lacking sewage infrastructure, the wealthy, Blackberry and iPod-laden colonia of NOVA (population 1.3 million) lacks traffic infrastructure. Neither is a model of prudent urban planning.
December 18, 2005 10:51 PM | Reply | Permalink
Slightly off-topic, but: the trip from downtown DC will be easier (a straight shot on US 50 to the Parole exit, then right to go under 50, right again once you've gone under 50, then left at the third light), and the store will be WAY less crowded once you're there.
note to chinshihtang: Kaine won the Tidewater area (Norfolk, VA Beach, Chesapeake, Newport News, Hampton, etc.) pretty decisively last month. He won Richmond proper by a sizable margin; I *think* he took the greater Richmond area.
Statewide, Kaine won or effectively tied Kilgore in all but three incorporated cities statewide: Bristol, Colonial Heights, and Poquoson, IIRC. He won in places like Lexington (home of VMI), Lynchburg (Jerry Falwell's city), and Danville (a Southside/NASCAR town), let alone places like Virginia Beach (home of Pat Robertson's empire) and Richmond. So the Dems are already doing what you suggest.
December 19, 2005 6:19 AM | Reply | Permalink
Lived up there my entire working life and couldn't wait to get out and move down here in the country.
There is too much government up there, and I don't mean that in a Grover sort of way. Byrd had the right idea to move it out of town to less inhabited places. How about sending more out to the Dakotas, Nebraska, etc?
December 19, 2005 7:40 AM | Reply | Permalink
Matt, next time you get a hankering for Trader Joe's, save yourself the Virginia traffic migraine and go up to Silver Spring instead. Maryland traffic is sane by comparison.
Shoot straight up 16th Street, turn right on East-West highway, then left on Colesville Road. It's about half a mile outside the Beltway on your right. Can't miss it.
December 19, 2005 11:49 AM | Reply | Permalink
But the advantages to this approach is it would take cars off of I-66 completely, reducing driving congestion, and aleviate parking problems at vienna. Express busses serve this route now and the lucky cna use them.
If only a way to get people from the I-66 corridor to the Tysons area without having to go to falls church and back through the new Tysons metrorail extension.
January 21, 2006 8:12 AM | Reply | Permalink