TPMCafe
« Bring It On | Home | Can The Elephant Change Its Stripes? »

Labor Victory on Both Coasts

user-pic

The trade union movement had three big election wins on both coasts last night. In California, a coalition of unions, unhindered by the split in the AFL-CIO, took ballot initiatives to defeat in California,and took the wind out of the Schwarzenegger reign with them. By defeating Propositions 74 and 75, against lengtheneing tenure time for teachers and dues check-off (permission to use union dues for political purposes) for public employees, the unions handed a huge defeat to the Republican governor, one that could even end up forcing him out of the race for re-election, but certainly showing his vulnerability.


In NJ, unions helped lead Jon Corzine to victory as governor and in New York City, the one "Republican" victory last night, unions helped elect Mike Bloomberg, who thanked the 'every day heroes' in his speech, referring by name to the municipal and public sector unions with whom he had finished negotiating new contracts in time for the election.( The Republicans can try to claim the Bloomberg win as a victory, but that's just silly. Bloomberg's running a liberal Democratic administration, with most of his key folks (including campaign consultants) who are Dems. I, for one, would have preferred that he come home to his party before this election--he could have easily won, I suspsect, in the Democratic Primary--)

The election showed that when politicians come swinging against unions, the unions can fight back-especially when they personalize their stories. The California unions ran an amazing campaign, sophisticated and coordinated. The Nurses, especially, led the charge, with the duo of Warren Beatty and Annette Bening at their side--and after all, what's not to like? And, the police unions ran terrific tv ads that captured the Nascar dad side of the spectrum, expressing their disappointment with a Governor whose public image and films play directly to those who wear the uniforms. While the California governor attacked the working people who make city and state government run, Bloomberg went out of his way to mention the union support by name, and express glowing support for the work they do-he went down the line, police, teachers,and sanitation workers--in his speech.

This election showed that unions can capture the public imagination--and that the individual unions can work together without a central labor federation. This bodes well for congressional bi-elections and of course for the Presidential election in 2008. 


8 Comments

| Leave a comment

Very happy to see Prop 75 be clearly defeated.  But I suspect we'll see something like it pop up around the country.  The battle was won, but the war goes on, and all that.  

A united labor got creamed in Minneapolis though. So not all good news last night.

Labor also racked up victory in Edison, New Jersey, where Jun Choi was elected mayor on a reform slate.  Choi focused on a variety of issues, including his opposition to a new Wal-Mart store, which garnered the support of several local unions including the Teamsters and UFCW.  In a corrupt local political culture, Choi touted his status as an uncorrupted outsider running in his first election. 

Keep an eye on Jun Choi. He looks like a rising star in New Jersey politics.

Instead of always playing defense, why don't Cal Democrates either pass a law or start a proposition to ban all political contributions by companies with contracts or applying for contracts with the State.  Force the corporations to play defense for once.

Great point here Jo-Ann:

The election showed that when politicians come swinging against unions, the unions can fight back-especially when they personalize their stories.
United "Labor" in California had, besides the money, an infallible issue of great importance that was almost impossible to screw up.

Governor Schwarzenegger learned a hard political lesson. You shouldn't attack teachers, nurses and fire and safety personnel as "special interest groups." You don't treat them as if they are creatures from a different planet.

Each individual citizen of the above groups in California IS a special interest ... but the special interest is that each individual citizen is a working, contributing, taxpaying individual, and in the majority are active voters.

In California's situation the previously populist Arnold Schwarzenegger has now placed himself in a position of being a lame duck governor and must overcome the cloud of shilling for corporate interest groups.

No doubt the Terminator began his bid for re-election last night by bleating that he must work hard "to find common ground." Yup! He now finds himself in the unenviable position of having to run on a platform of proving to the electorate that he can negotiate with the legislature in a non-partisan manner to get the job done for all the special citizens of the state.

Proposition 75 losing 53/46 was of great importance. But what's been overshadowed was where the states electorate easily crossed partisan battle lines with the 63/34 NO to the veiled attempt to "starve the beast" found in Prop 76.

Either the governor deals faithfully to work on funding the programs or it may just be Hasta la vista baby!


The wins in California were very important.  But the union coalition did not seem to me to be particularly cohesive.  Some of the splits were traditional, and some were new, as a result of the AFL split.  I don't want to take away from the work of any union or point fingers but I do think it is possible to use victory to gloss over a real problem.  Defeating initiatives is a function of message, organization and dollars.  We were fine on the first part, but I suspect the weaknesses of the second part contributed somewhat to the very high price we paid for these wins.  I suspect there will be a greater challenge maintaining the momentum from this fight into the 2006 election than we had on the first paycheck deception fight because we've weakened the structure.

Could you provide a little background on Minneapolis?  I heard that there was a D-D contest in St. Paul and that the one who had backed Bush lost.  Also to rain a little on the parade, here in Seattle there was a pretty intense effort to get a labor slate elected to the Seattle Port Commission and we got creamed.  There was also a rallying around Ron Sims for King County Executive (probably the most progressive politician in the state) who was looking bad for a while but pulled it out.  However it's hard to tell how much credit labor can take for that because it came out about three weeks ago that his opponent had beaten up his own mother (!)

Carl

Labor support didn't prevail

McLaughlin had the support of the city's unions, including Local 82 of the Minneapolis firefighters. President Tom Thornberg said Rybak's win was a blow to labor.

"It's really inconceivable for me, as big a labor town as Minneapolis is, that the candidate that is endorsed by all of labor can't win," he said. "We'll have to do some evaluating."

The Police Federation also endorsed McLaughlin and had pledged to spend big money to defeat Rybak.

From Star-Tribune http://www.startribune.com/stories/587/5716084.html 

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address