Base First
Let's get a thread going among those who watched the President's press event in Mobile about an hour ago. This was Bush's third major public statement on the disaster after two strangely distant and defensive appearances, and it doesn't look like he's any more in touch.
You've got tens of thousands of people in New Orleans and the surrounding areas screaming for federal help, four days after the hurricane and three days after the flooding of the city, and Bush's first priority in his personal disaster relief tour is to drop down in Alabama, get a completely bogus "briefing" in front of the cameras, and then stand around yucking it up with Republican politicians in golf clothes.
You've got tens of thousands of people in New Orleans and the surrounding areas screaming for federal help, four days after the hurricane and three days after the flooding of the city, and Bush's first priority in his personal disaster relief tour is to drop down in Alabama, get a completely bogus "briefing" in front of the cameras, and then stand around yucking it up with Republican politicians in golf clothes.
High points included Bush's jocular assurance that "we're going to rebuild Trent Lott's big home" (we've all been worried about that), and his congratulations to FEMA Director Michael Brown, who is undoubtedly the least popular man in New Orleans right now, that "You're doing a great job, Brownie!" (Wonder who was in charge of the relief effort that Bush earlier today said was "unacceptable"?)
Look, I know the people of southern Mississippi and parts of Alabama have suffered enormously, and deserve attention. But for the most part these areas are into the recovery stage of the disaster. It's Louisiana that most needs immediate relief.
Yes, Bush is later making his way to New Orleans, and will meet with Mayor Nagin at the airport; I'd be real surprised if any cameras are allowed anywhere near that encounter. I guess the point of the Mobile event was to get one positive, upbeat photo op, lend the presidential aura to two Republican governors, and maybe even to express solidarity with the famously conservative voters of the region, many thousands of whom have pretty much lost everything.
But it struck me as a very peculiar "first base"--or maybe I should say "base first"--stop on a trip that's supposed to show the awesome power of the federal government to succor the suffering in Louisiana.
2:00 UPDATE: Just watched another weird Bush press appearance after a "walking tour" of Biloxi. More rambling and disconnected talk; more defensive words and body language; and a not-so-subtle undertone suggesting the crisis in Louisiana--as opposed to Mississippi--was attributable to local (i.e., Democratic) elected officials. Next stop: New Orleans.
Yes, Bush is later making his way to New Orleans, and will meet with Mayor Nagin at the airport; I'd be real surprised if any cameras are allowed anywhere near that encounter. I guess the point of the Mobile event was to get one positive, upbeat photo op, lend the presidential aura to two Republican governors, and maybe even to express solidarity with the famously conservative voters of the region, many thousands of whom have pretty much lost everything.
But it struck me as a very peculiar "first base"--or maybe I should say "base first"--stop on a trip that's supposed to show the awesome power of the federal government to succor the suffering in Louisiana.
2:00 UPDATE: Just watched another weird Bush press appearance after a "walking tour" of Biloxi. More rambling and disconnected talk; more defensive words and body language; and a not-so-subtle undertone suggesting the crisis in Louisiana--as opposed to Mississippi--was attributable to local (i.e., Democratic) elected officials. Next stop: New Orleans.
Advertisement












Comments (43)
High points included Bush's jocular assurance that "we're going to rebuild Trent Lott's big home" (we've all been worried about that), and his congratulations to FEMA Director Michael Brown, who is undoubtedly the least popular man in New Orleans right now, that "You're doing a great job, Brownie!" (Wonder who was in charge of the relief effort that Bush earlier today said was "unacceptable"?)
I didn't see the photo-op but...
WHAT?!?!?! He praised FEMA's response and pledged to rebuild Lott's home?
Hey Mr. President...why don't you roll up your sleeves, help out, and if not just go back to DC and help Trent work on the plans for his new home.
September 2, 2005 10:06 AM | Reply | Permalink
I've come to the uneasy realization that paying attention to anything having to dfo with the Bush administration is like watching the escaped inmates of a mental ward.
Bush goes to an Alabama golf course, Condi Rice physically has a citizen removed from a boutique shoe store for the woman questioning why she's worried about new shoes while NO drowns, and that's the tip of an iceburg of insanity.
September 2, 2005 10:07 AM | Reply | Permalink
I hope people don't play politics during this period of time... There'll be ample time for politics. But now's the time to focus attention, our compassion and our resources on helping people who need help" (President Bush, 9/1/05).
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/4204754.stm
"It gives us cover," said one House Republican strategist, speaking on the condition of anonymity because of the political sensitivity of the disaster. "Now everything is going to be about putting together a relief package quickly" (LA Times).
http://www.latimes.com/news/poli...ack=1&cset=true
...And now the RNC is pushing the Senate hard to kill the estate tax. We must hold their feet to the fire, every conservative, every Republican, every echo chamber gas bag, for all the fun they've had for so many years dishing the "liberal big government nanny state."
September 2, 2005 10:09 AM | Reply | Permalink
"and will meet with Mayor Nagin at the airport; I'd be real surprised if any cameras are allowed anywhere near that encounter."
Wouldn't do to be on camera if the mayor decides it's appropriate to slap him.
dc
September 2, 2005 10:12 AM | Reply | Permalink
President:
Fuck Trent Lott. And his new fucking porch.
Go ahead. Troll rate me.
Some things need to be said, and I don't mind taking the hit to say it.
September 2, 2005 10:17 AM | Reply | Permalink
I hope the Mayor gives the President hell.
Here's a link to the transcript of Nagin's emotional and heartfelt interview last night with WWL, if everyone hasn't read or heard it yet.
September 2, 2005 10:21 AM | Reply | Permalink
Watch out for an upcoming photo-op as Bush arrives in New Orleans at the head of long convoys of supplies and buses (all of which seem to have been delayed for this opportunity).
Shades of a bullhorn on a pile of rubble!
I am embarassed and ashamed. Talk about playing politics! W has no integrity and is not a leader.
Reminder, Trent Lott's house in Pascagoula which was lost was a getaway house on the gulf. His real home is in Jackson.
September 2, 2005 10:23 AM | Reply | Permalink
Wouldn't do to be on camera if the mayor decides it's appropriate to slap him.
dc
I hope Nagin doesn't slap him...I just hope he insists the president take a trip with him to tour the Convention Center.
September 2, 2005 10:23 AM | Reply | Permalink
Does it strike anyone else as an amazing coincidence that Bush arrives in the area at the exact moment food and aid arrives in New Orleans?
September 2, 2005 10:37 AM | Reply | Permalink
Senate Democrats need to lead and the only way to do it is force the Republicans into action. Rally the American people to hold these idiots to account.
Until this mess is fixed, and these idiots are held accountable nothing gets through. For example.
No John Roberts hearings. Instead hearings into FEMA incompentance. Hold hearings for DHS mismannagement before John Roberts.
No hearings of any sort until there is accountability and action. NOTHING!
No legislation on any matter that does not bring help to the gulf or accountability to the people on what happened.
No Estate Tax repeal. Repeal the give aways to the energy companies and the energy and highway pork.
Repeal of the bankruptcy bill, repeal of tax cuts for the rich.
It is time to reach across the isle with baseball bats to forge working alliances with moderates and shame them into working with us.
The Senate can do this. Reid is the person to lead it, but every Democrat and Moderate Republican should be on the team.
It is time for a political shift, and one won't occur if it is business as ususal. It's time for business UNUSUAL.
Take Action!
September 2, 2005 10:39 AM | Reply | Permalink
Memo to Ed:
We know the Republicans are fucked up. This is the effect of Republican policies and philosophy coming together at once.
But what I want to know is where are the Democrats, Ed? Will your gutless party now get off its ass and actually do something about becoming a credible opposition party? So your party lacked the courage to criticize Bush for lying us into this horrible war. And so your party's best response to that quagmire is to be even more pro-war than Bush is. Fine. We can all debate tactics and strategies.
But, Ed, this is different. This administration is presiding over the mismanagement of a disaster that is causing needless deaths of Americans right here at home. I've not seen Americans so appalled at the Cheney/Rove Administration at any time since Dear Leader became president.
So, please Ed. It's great that you criticize Bush. I love it, and I can't get enough of it. But tell me now: Will the Democrats finally, finally get their heads out of their asses and begin to take this country back before it's too late?
Thanks for listening.
September 2, 2005 10:43 AM | Reply | Permalink
I just hope he insists the president take a trip with him to tour the Convention Center.
Bush wouldn't dare.
September 2, 2005 10:47 AM | Reply | Permalink
Just watch as things unfold in the months ahead. The Bush team and FEMA incompetent Michael Brown and this bunch have no idea what they are going to do. The Bush mantra is to do things on the cheap (the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq being prime examples), and this is one situation where that approach will blow up in their faces. This isn't just about getting food and supplies into the city. That's the easy part. We also must find housing for 100,000-300,000 American refugees. We must seal the levees and drain the city of New Orleans. The government must lead a MASSIVE cleanup and restoraton project to the get the city functional again.
And then, after all that, there will still be 250,000 people whose homes were destroyed or ruined by the flooding. Is the Bush team ready to call up massive construction teams to rebuild this city quickly, or will it be every man for himself?
Even the best, most efficient government (as we had under Clinton) would be hard-pressed to face this challenge. But with Bush and his cronies in charge, things are definitely going to get worse before they get better.
September 2, 2005 10:48 AM | Reply | Permalink
Who knows if these people are planning ahead with any more capability than they are handling the current situation. Personally I think they should be setting up a coordinated effort with Mayors across the country to send the refugees to different cities. If we could get 500 cities to take a 1000 people each, or maybe 100 cities to take 5000 each, then at least these refugees would have somewhere to stay for the next 2-3 months while New Orleans is made partially livable again.
Aren't there hundreds of dying towns in North Dakota, South Dakota, Montana, and other Midwest states that could accept an influx of residents? I remember reading stories over the past few years about Midwest senators trying to lure new residents to their rapidly depleting towns. Perhaps we should just temporarily bus some people to these places, rather than crowded hellholes like the Astrodome.
But don't expect the Bush team to try this. They are unimaginative and incompetent. We'll spend the next few years dissecting their mistakes while they pretend that "no one could have foreseen the tragedy". It's happening RIGHT NOW and they aren't doing anything.
September 2, 2005 10:53 AM | Reply | Permalink
The Trent Lott comment was a bit tone-deaf and awkward, but the content wasn't fundamentally offensive. He was trying to make a rah-rah statement about rebuilding Mississippi, which is a great thing to say. He just it badly.
September 2, 2005 11:12 AM | Reply | Permalink
Bush wouldn't dare.
He doesn't have the balls to do that...and if somehow he found a pair and went he'd be getting much more then a slap.
September 2, 2005 11:15 AM | Reply | Permalink
A point of clarification, and with all due respect, Ed, we're not really dealing with a RELIEF effort in New Orleans. We're dealing with a SEARCH AND RESCUE effort. What relief there is has been established in alternate cities, my hometown Houston being the most visible. I just returned from the Astrodome where the situtation is both one of hope and despair. Hundreds of locals are streaming into the arena complex to donate food and clothing and volunteer. But there are countless refugees wandering the grounds in a state of shock and confusion. We need more volunteers. And we need a lot more coordination.
In New Orleans, the Coast Guard and National Guard are still retrieving trapped survivors from flooded houses and buildings. And we are poised for an unrelenting outbreak of disease. Let's keep in mind that in addition to the thousands of displaced people, millions of disease-carrying rats have now come out of hiding.
If you're reading this and want to do something, please donote to the Red Cross immediately, and specify that your donation of food, clothing or money go directly to the victims of Katrina.
September 2, 2005 11:15 AM | Reply | Permalink
no, it wasn't just tone deaf and awkward, it was sadly typical. bush has no ability to relate to people he doesn't know: they exist as merest abstractions. so the idea that the way to "rally" anyone is by saying that trent lott's house will be rebuilt enteres his puny little brain because he knows trent lott. the idea that there are hundreds of thousands, if not several million people with bigger problems than trent lott's second home has no actual meaning to this shallow little man. no excuses for bush on anything. he long ago used up his get out of jail free card.
September 2, 2005 11:19 AM | Reply | Permalink
Hey Ed,
Where in the hell has the DLC and its most prominent members been on LEADING during the catastrophe. I received email alerts from Howard Dean and John Kerry asking me to contribute to the Red Cross. Wesley Clark rightly charged Bush with incompetence. Al Sharpton got off the couch and went to the Superdome. Hell, I even got an email from Expedia and United Airlines asking me to contribute.
What did I get from Hillary Clinton, Biden, Bayh, or Lieberman - ZERO. The last time I checked they were all United States Senators who were elected to LEAD the United States. Do you and they not understand that at a time when a major US city is getting wiped off the map it isn't enough to sit in Washington DC and take shots at Bush.
We all KNOW that his policies are literally killing the citizens of the United States. What I want to know is why the Democrats didn't rent buses and trucks in Virginia, fill them with water and food, and drive them to New Orleans. I want to know why every single Democrat in congress isn't going on the air right now to ask their constituents to help.
I want to know what the Democrats and stood by silently while the Republicans and lead our country to the brink of disaster. I want to know why every Democrat isn't raising holy hell about Iraq. I want to know that the Democrats are voting for pork barrel travesties like the Highway Bill that had millions for a bridge to know where in Alaska, but underfunded the levees in New Orleans. In a similar vein, I want to know why Seattle can't get adequate funding for a major highway running through downtown that the engineers say will definitely collapse with the next earthquake.
Don't tell me that you can't do anything because you don't control any branch of government. That is pure BS. I want to know what the Democratic leadership is actually going to do to take back control and set this country on the right course. And given the complete silence and lack of leadership of Clinton, Biden, Bayh, Vilsack and the rest of the DLC, how in the world will they find the nerve to ask for my vote in the primaries.
It isn't enough to point out Bush's failings. We KNOW he is a failure. What are the Democrats going to do about it is the question. So far, on issues ranging from Iraq to Katrina, the only person worthy of my vote is Wes Clark. The rest of the Dems, especially Clinton(s) are simply embarassments to a party that I hold dear.
September 2, 2005 11:32 AM | Reply | Permalink
I'm on several other e-mail lists because of my hobby as a show dog breeder. We have been hearing from many evacuees that FEMA has been placing restrictions on the "qualified" applicants for aid. Apparently, FEMA is also telling those who have suffered total losses that it may be several MONTHS before they will release any funds - and, of course, you must fit their RACIAL criteria.
And then we have Bush fumbling in the darkness for a sign of intelligent life in his brain.
ds
September 2, 2005 11:42 AM | Reply | Permalink
wow, let me just second cscs' recommendation to READ THIS TRANSCRIPT. just make sure you have some kleenex handy.
September 2, 2005 11:43 AM | Reply | Permalink
I watched the news coverage of Bush on his walking-tour photo op in Mississippi. Two distraught African American women appeared to have been steered Bush's way for a photo op. Bush looked more concerned with positioning them for a photo op--then of actually listening to what they were saying. You could hear the cameras clicking as he hugged them, and he kept them close to him as he manuevered them for the cameras.
There was something very cold about the entire encounter--yet I bet the pictures will make Bush look good.
September 2, 2005 11:44 AM | Reply | Permalink
I totally agree that his comment about Lott's house went way beyong "tone deaf". It was sick. Tasteless, given the emergency that is still going on. I'm sure he intended the comment to be a humorous part of his "Rah rah! Rebuild Mississippi" speech, but it really illustrates that he is clueless as to how such statements come across to the average person.
There is something pathologically wrong with the Bush family and the crowd they surround themselves with. The 5-week vacations, the "beautiful mind" comment by Bar, Poppy's golfing during Desert Storm, Condi's shoe shopping...these are Marie Antoinettes of the highest order. Their sense of aristocratic entitlement is disgusting; their flippant comments during national disasters tells you all you need to know about the way they see the world and their priveleged position in it.
It's bad enough that they view themselves as a special class, but it's utterly inexcusable that they are totally oblivious to how their attitude comes across to others.
September 2, 2005 11:53 AM | Reply | Permalink
Ed, I'm glad you've noticed that while you and the rest of the Democratic Party have advised not politicizing this disaster (we wouldn't want to be shrill, would we), Bush et al are setting up Blanco and Nagin to take the fall for this.
So, what are you going to do about it?
If you read these blogs, if you read recent polls, you can see one unmistakable message for Democrats: For God's sake, turn and fight!
September 2, 2005 11:54 AM | Reply | Permalink
Um hello...these aren't your typical refugees.
You really think these city councils are going to just open their doors to a bunch of poor black urbanites?
Right now they'd be more embraced if they were African, without the full rights (theoretically) of citizenship.
Lets talk real here.
September 2, 2005 12:08 PM | Reply | Permalink
CBC, Wexler and Wes Clark are on record.
It's going to take a popular Senator and leader to provide these cowards the backbone to speak out and say what everyone in America is thinking.
September 2, 2005 12:14 PM | Reply | Permalink
I'm sorry, did you say that he visted a "golf course" in Alabama?
You know after yesterday, I didn't think that Bush could sink any lower. I was wrong.
September 2, 2005 12:26 PM | Reply | Permalink
Watch out for an upcoming photo-op as Bush arrives in New Orleans at the head of long convoys of supplies and buses (all of which seem to have been delayed for this opportunity).
I thought only I was cynical enough to have thought that. It is remarkable that the photo ops of supplies and the President seem to be more coordinated than anything that has happened all week.
September 2, 2005 12:39 PM | Reply | Permalink
Senate Democrats need to lead and the only way to do it is force the Republicans into action. Rally the American people to hold these idiots to account. Until this mess is fixed, and these idiots are held accountable nothing gets through. For example. No John Roberts hearings. Instead hearings into FEMA incompentance. Hold hearings for DHS mismannagement before John Roberts. No hearings of any sort until there is accountability and action. NOTHING! No legislation on any matter that does not bring help to the gulf or accountability to the people on what happened.
I think this is an excellent idea. A coalition of legislators (probably mostly Democrats, but Republicans would be welcome, too) should draw up a list of a few clear, critical accountability issues that need to be dealt with, and then paralyze all government actions unrelated to the rescue and relief efforts on the Gulf Coast or the situation in Iraq, until their demands are met. If this administration won't hold themselves accountable for anything, then we have to do it -- it's way past being a partisan issue at this point; it's for the security of our nation.
September 2, 2005 1:05 PM | Reply | Permalink
According to Atrios, Cafferty just used my observation about the timing of Bush's visit on The Situation Room.
http://atrios.blogspot.com/2005_08_28_atrios_archive.html#1125690
65817590840
Funny, I sent that comment into CNN just before I posted it here.
September 2, 2005 1:06 PM | Reply | Permalink
vmckimmey,
I also think this post would be a good one to move to one of the main discussion tables. Maybe a moderator could do this, or maybe you could re-post this as a discussion post?
September 2, 2005 1:09 PM | Reply | Permalink
Go ahead. Troll rate me. cscs
Not exactly a macho challenge on this board, eh wot, cscs?
September 2, 2005 1:09 PM | Reply | Permalink
thanks, but I don't know how to do that.
vern
September 2, 2005 1:32 PM | Reply | Permalink
ND is depopulated because it's hard to make a living there and the temperature goes down to -40 with a +20 mph wind. Forget that one.
September 2, 2005 1:35 PM | Reply | Permalink
I received email from Hillary about the Hurricane.
September 2, 2005 2:09 PM | Reply | Permalink
DailyKos has a transcript of this encounter with the two women. One says her child has been evacuated somewhere else. Both women are looking for clothes. The subsequent conversation may as well have been written for an absurdist play or the Cabinet of Dr. Caligari.
Bush tell sthem there's a salvation army outlet down the road.
Someone chimes in that it's wiped out.
Bush insists they go down the road.
Someone suggests there's a truck there.
The women won't leave, they need clothes.
Someone chimes in that there are no clothes on the truck - just food and water.
Bush says, Well, then what you need is food and water then. And he ambles off down the road with them.
Surreal.
September 2, 2005 2:39 PM | Reply | Permalink
Hi Vern,
Yeah, it's not the most intuitive thing... If you look at that little "MyTPMCafe" thing on the right sidebar, there's a link that says "Discuss". When you click on that, you get to the screen where you can submit a discussion post. First you choose the "table" that you want to post to -- I'm thinking the Democrats or Misc. Politics tables might be good for this one -- then you give your post a title, and then enter the "intro" and "body" text. The "intro" is the summary, "above the fold" stuff, and the "body" is the stuff that readers see when they click on "Continue reading." If you don't want to separate the post into two sections, you can just put everything in the "intro".
I hope you'll submit it -- I know I'll be voting for it!
September 2, 2005 2:53 PM | Reply | Permalink
I just did it. thanks Nascardaughter.
September 2, 2005 4:57 PM | Reply | Permalink
I ain't wasting my time waiting to hear the "pop".
September 2, 2005 4:58 PM | Reply | Permalink
cool. just voted for it...
September 2, 2005 5:24 PM | Reply | Permalink
"No John Roberts hearings. Instead hearings into FEMA incompentance"
Be carefull. The R's will see to it that the Mayor of NO and the Governor of LA are invited to the party and the proceedings may not go as you would like, politically.
September 3, 2005 4:54 AM | Reply | Permalink
"Some things need to be said, and I don't mind taking the hit to say it. "
Yeah, you are really taking a bold stand on this site! What a wonderful example of courage and sacrific!
September 3, 2005 5:06 AM | Reply | Permalink
Well, at least there were no bullhorns in sight yesterday.
I'm sure Bush was hoping that this visit would give him the kind of poll results which he got for his visit to the rubble of the WTC after 3/11.
Why else would Karl Rove accompany him? My wife used the term 'artistic director' to describe Rove's credit in today's drama to help the Bush image.
If you noted the coverage carefully, it was clear that the encounters with people were well stage managed with the 'ordinary citizens' having been carefully selected. Except for the visit to the Salvation Army field service truck, you saw no other victims of Katrina in the background. The area had, as usual, been swept clean of people who might say or do something contrary to the desired image.
You'll also notice that even with the massive infusion of troops in the morning Bush didn't meet any of Katrina's victims in New Orleans. He only was on the ground at the airport which is relatively easy to secure. The Secret Service must have said that the risk was too great in the city or at either the Convention Center or the Superdome.
I still have symptoms of apoplexy.
September 3, 2005 7:22 AM | Reply | Permalink